How good is this conference?: evaluating conference reviewing and selectivity
نویسندگان
چکیده
Peer reviewing of papers is the mainstay of modern academic publishing but it has well known problems. In this paper, we take a statistical modelling view to show a particular problem in the use of selectivity measures to indicate the quality of a conference. One key problem with the process of conference reviewing is the failure to make a useful feedback loop between the referees of the papers accepted at the conference and their importance, acceptance and relevance to the audience. In addition, we make some new criticisms of selectivity as a measure of quality.
منابع مشابه
Special Issue for 11th International Conference of Iranian Operations Research Society
This is a special issue of the Iranian Journal of Operations Research that includes some of the invited talks presented at the 11th international conference of the Iranian Operations Research Society (IORS), organized jointly by IORS and Razi University of Kermanshah and held at the Razi University, Kermanshah, Iran, May 2-4, 2018. The IORS conference is held annually and is the main event ...
متن کاملSpecial Issue for 13th International Industrial Engineering Conference (IIEC 2017)
This special issue is a collection of refereed articles selected from the 13th International Industrial Engineering Conference (IIEC 2017). The initial selection was made by Dr. Hamed Fazlollahtabar who also wrote the following description. The accepted articles were reviewed going through the usual reviewing process of IJOR. Nezam Mahdavi-Amiri Editor-in-Chief &nbs...
متن کاملProviding a multidimensional measurement model for assessing quality of sport tourism services: Empirical evidence from sport conference as sport event tourism
This study aimed to empirically develop a reliable and valid model specifically for measuring service quality of sport conferences as sport event tourism. To assess the model which has been established based on the survey, data gathered from 136 of attendees in sport conference. Finding of this study showed that participants form their service quality perceptions based on their evaluations of 4...
متن کاملA Linguistic Analysis of Conference Titles in Applied Linguistics
Over the past twenty-five years, researchers have expressed considerable interest in titles of academic publications. Unfortunately, conference paper titles (CPTs) have only recently begun to receive attention. The aim of this study, therefore, is to investigate the text length, syntactic structure, and lexicon of CPTs in Applied Linguistics. A data set of 698 titles was selected from the 2008 ...
متن کاملA Linguistic Analysis of Conference Titles in Applied Linguistics
Over the past twenty-five years, researchers have expressed considerable interest in titles of academic publications. Unfortunately, conference paper titles (CPTs) have only recently begun to receive attention. The aim of this study, therefore, is to investigate the text length, syntactic structure, and lexicon of CPTs in Applied Linguistics. A data set of 698 titles was selected from the 2008 ...
متن کامل